In this article, we compare Puffy vs Amerisleep AS3 Mattress, two mattresses from the same product category. We have Puffy, which is one of the best beds available with cooling cloud™ technology, and Amerisleep AS3, which is one of the original foam mattresses.
Our review ignores all the marketing fluff you see in most ads. Instead, we get down to what actually matters with these two mattresses. Basically, both these brands are pretty promising.
These two beds can easily be used with adjustable bases. You may prefer either of these two great products over their competition if you like the feeling of quilted foam. These are great choices for US residents because of they all ship directly to your door in a box.
Which Mattress is Right for You?
Choose the Puffy Mattress If You Like:
- To save money (costs less than Amerisleep AS3)
- A lifetime warranty (Puffy backs up their mattress for life, while Amerisleep AS3 has a 20-year warranty)
- To sleep cooler (Puffy uses gel infused memory foam that sleeps cooler than the open-cell memory foam of Amerisleep AS3)
Choose the Amerisleep AS3 Mattress If You Like:
- A thicker mattress (it is 12” thick and Puffy is 10” thick)
- More support, especially if you have a heavier body
Both mattresses are manufactured in the USA, work for all sleeping positions, and ship within 1 to 5 working days.
You can find a deeper level of information about either mattress in our full reviews:
Puffy vs. Amerisleep AS3 Mattress (Detailed Review)
Construction and MaterialsThe Amerisleep AS3 wins this category.
Feel and FirmnessThe Amerisleep wins this category.
Motion Transfer and SinkageThe Puffy works better on motion transfer, but AS3 works better on Sinkage.
Sleeping CoolThe Puffy wins this category.
PricingThe Puffy wins this category.
Customer ServiceThe Puffy wins this category.
|Puffy Mattress||Amerisleep AS3 Mattress|
|Price of Queen ($)||950||1,199|
|Number of Layers||3||3|
|Comfort Level||Medium Firm||Medium|
|Warranty||Lifetime Warranty||20 Year Warranty|
In terms of cost-based value and quality, the Puffy is a better choice than the Amerisleep AS3. In terms of construction, Amerisleep AS3 provides excellent support and comfort.
As far as performance is concerned, Puffy seems to be the best option in terms of motion transfer and sleeping cool. The three layers of this mattress work together to provide better contouring and resilience for increased motion isolation. Also, the gel-infused foam offers superior heat dissipation.
As far as support is concerned, the 12-inch Amerisleep AS3 seems to offer greater support compared to the Puffy. You also do not sink in too much, which is great for back and stomach sleepers. Both have sleep trials that are long enough.
The Puffy brand seems to be the best as far as customer service is concerned. You get a lifetime warranty. With that said, our overall winner is the Puffy mattress. However, the final decision relies entirely on your preferences and budget.