After reading our in-depth review of Puffy vs. Casper Mattress, you’ll know if either suits your needs. The whole bed-in-a-box industry is built on the belief that a universally high performing all-foam mattress exists in the market, and you can get to sleep on it without digging too deep into your pockets. We certainly agree.
Among the many bed-in-a-box mattresses that we have come across, we found two intriguing options (Puffy and Casper) that we believe are the best for those who desire an all-foam mattress.
The right choice depends entirely on what kind of sleeper you are, your preferred softness, and how much you are willing to spend for optimum comfort and support. In this article, we have compared the most important features of the two beds for you.
We seek to help you make the best purchasing decision between these two great brands.
Which Mattress is Right for You?
Choose the Puffy Mattress if You Like
- To save money (Puffy mattress is cheaper than the Casper mattress, but not by too much)
- A longer sleep trial (Puffy offers a longer home trial period than Casper)
- A lifetime warranty (Puffy has a never-ending warranty and Casper has a 10-year limited warranty)
Choose the Casper Mattress if You Like
- A famous brand, Casper is one of the biggest online mattress brands
- A strong mattress construction (Casper has 4 layers and Puffy has 3 layers)
- Superior comfort (high-density memory foam in the Casper mattress provides superior comfort)
Both mattresses are 10-inches thick, made in the USA, and are delivered within 1 to 5 business days. And both of them work for almost all sleeping positions. But if you’re a pure side sleeper, neither of them are the best choice
Side sleepers will save time by going to our Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers review.
Puffy vs. Casper Mattress (Detailed Review)
Construction and MaterialsThe Casper mattress wins this category.
Feel and FirmnessThe Casper mattress wins this category. It provides better relief for shoulder and hip pain
Motion Transfer and SinkageIf you want a pushback feeling, Casper is the winner. If you just want the contouring provided by memory foam, then Puffy works better. .
Sleeping CoolThe Casper mattress wins this category.
PricingThe Puffy mattress wins this category.
Customer ServiceThe Puffy mattress wins this category.
|Puffy Mattress||Casper Mattress|
|Price of Queen ($)||950||995|
|Number of Layers||3||4|
|Comfort Level||Medium Firm||Medium|
|Warranty||Lifetime Warranty||10 Year Limited Warranty|
These two foam mattresses provide similar value, but with a few major differences in construction. According to our findings, the Casper has a more solid construction compared to the Puffy, and that is probably why it is pricier.
However, Puffy is the better choice when it comes to motion transfer and sleeping cool. The three foam layers of Puffy offer greater motion isolation than the combined four foam layers of Casper.
While the Puffy is the most ideal choice for side and back sleepers, the Casper seems to be a reliable choice for almost all sleeping positions. However, it may not perform extremely well for stomach sleepers.
In terms of customer service, Puffy offers a longer trial period and a more promising warranty. With that said, our overall winner is the Puffy mattress, but the final buying decision depends on your budget and preferences.